Skip to content
Guide Germany
DE
Menu

Prepaid or Contract: Which Should You Pick in Germany? (2026)

By Jules de Bruin, Market ResearcherUpdated August 20 2026 | Found helpful by 8 others

Prepaid is the right first choice for almost anyone new to Germany, because it is the only option that needs no German address, no German bank account and no SCHUFA record. It is also cheaper: EUR 8.99 for 25 GB against EUR 19.99 for 15 GB on the cheapest network-operator contract. Both models require identity verification. The catch on prepaid is the 28-day cycle, which bills 13 times a year.

Jump to section

Which Is Better, Prepaid or a Contract?

Choose prepaid if...

  • You have no German address or SEPA direct debit yet.
  • You have no SCHUFA record, which is normal in your first months.
  • You want no minimum term and the lowest price per GB.

Choose a contract if...

  • You have a stable German address and a SEPA mandate.
  • You want the higher data tiers, up to unlimited.
  • You want a calendar-month bill and accept a 24-month term.

How Do Prepaid and Contract Compare?

What Is the 28-Day Cycle Trap?

Most German prepaid tariffs renew every 28 days rather than on the calendar month. Thirteen of those cycles fit into a year, so a tariff sold as EUR 8.99 is really about EUR 9.74 a month, and one sold as EUR 9.95 costs near EUR 129 a year. That gap is large enough to flip a comparison, which is why every price on this site is labelled with its cycle.

Two no-contract tariffs avoid it entirely: fraenk, EUR 10 for 25 GB on the Telekom network, and SIMon mobile, EUR 9.99 for 50 GB on Vodafone. Both are calendar-month subscriptions and both are monthly cancellable, so you get contract-style billing without a 24-month commitment.

Who Should Choose Prepaid or a Contract?

Newcomers, students and short-stay visitors should start with prepaid, because a contract is not realistically available before the address registration and SCHUFA record exist. Long-term residents who want 100 GB or more, or an unlimited tariff, will find those tiers on contract: Telekom MagentaMobil runs from EUR 29.95 for 20 GB up to EUR 84.95 unlimited, Vodafone Mobil from EUR 29.99 for 25 GB up to EUR 79.99 unlimited, and 1&1 sells 150 GB for EUR 19.99 online only.

If you are under 28, check the youth tariffs before signing an adult one: Telekom MagentaMobil M Young is EUR 24.95 for 100 GB in the first 24 months, Vodafone Mobil Young M is EUR 27.99 for 200 GB, and O2 Mobile S young is EUR 14.99 for 15 GB up to your 29th birthday. The gate is date of birth, not enrolment, so no student proof is needed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is prepaid cheaper than a contract in Germany?

For most individual users, yes. The value-brand floor is EUR 8.99 for 25 GB with unlimited calls and SMS, against EUR 19.99 for 15 GB on O2 Mobile S, the cheapest contract entry from a network operator. Read the cycle before comparing: EUR 8.99 renews every 28 days, which is 13 payments a year, about EUR 9.74 a month.

Can a newcomer get a contract tariff?

Usually not in the first weeks. Contract tariffs from Telekom, Vodafone, O2 and 1&1 need a German address, a SEPA direct debit and a SCHUFA credit check. Prepaid needs none of those, only identity verification.

Do I need ID either way?

Yes. Identity verification is mandatory on every German SIM, prepaid included. VideoIdent works with any passport, 24/7, and activation takes minutes to hours afterwards. Even SIMs from a vending machine have to be verified online before they work.

When does a contract make sense?

When you already have a German address and a SEPA mandate and want a calendar-month bill or the higher data tiers, for example Telekom MagentaMobil L at EUR 59.95 for 100 GB or MagentaMobil XL at EUR 84.95 unlimited. If you only want calendar-month billing, fraenk and SIMon mobile give you that without a 24-month term.